The brewing controversy in australia surrounding the application of. Corporations act 2001 sect 553c insolvent companies. More particularly, forges insolvency, coupled with hamersleys counterclaim for damages, meant that section 553c of the corporations act 2001 cth was engaged, and consequently, leave to enforce the determination should be refused. Corporations act refers to a charge created in any way. Corporations act 2001 sect 533 reports by liquidator. The relevant time for determining notice of insolvency for the purposes of s 553c2 was the time of entry into the subcontract.
A breach of this duty exposes the directors to penalties such as personal liability for future debts incurred, including during any informal. Corporations law setoff provisions for insolvent companies under s 553c whether notice of insolvency precludes setoff under s 553c2. It has been held that automatic set off under s 553c of the corporations act 2001 cth precludes companies in liquidation from taking advantage of. This may only occur in situations where the creditor. For our purposes the relevant section is section 553c of the corporations act which provides. Can a setoff under s 553c be relied on as a defence to the various statutory recovery claims available to a company s liquidator under the corporations act e. Corporations act 2001 sect 553c insolvent companiesmutual.
Conflict between section 553c and the sop act resolved. It produces a balance upon which the winding up administration can proceed. All sections s, chapters chs, parts pts, divisions divs and subdivisions. The case turned on whether the subcontractors claim to judgment under section 16 of the sop act failed because of the operation of section 553c of the corporations act. As a result, adjudicators will still be asked to determine what is due from the principal to the insolvent contractor, but this liability may be. The setoff under section 553c is selfexecuting it occurs automatically at the time of liquidation. The case demonstrates that although a principal is generally precluded from relying on a setoff or counterclaim in certain contexts under the building and construction industry security of payment act 2002 vic bcisp act, due to the operation of section 553c of the corporations act 2001 cth corporations act, this does not apply if the. This is a compilation of the corporations act 2001 as in force on 19 july 20. In cinema plus ltd administrators appointed v australia and new zealand banking group,7 the question of whether a banks contractual right to combine a customers accounts gave rise to a charge arose.
Act discussed in 3 below, it has wide powers to make orders for the benefit of the companys creditors. Hamersley iron pty ltd v forge group power pty ltd in liq 2017 wasc 152 statutory setoff under s 553c corporations act reigns supreme in liquidation matters. Accounting standards made under section 32 of the corporations act 1989 1442. Setoff against statutory avoidance and insolvent trading. Kwm forging ahead dealing with insolvent contractors. Administrators means barry frederic kogan, jason preston and katherine sozou in their capacities as the voluntary administrators of the companies. Insolvency practitioners pursuing unfair preference claims should give consideration to a recent queensland district court judgment which has endorsed the application of section 553c of the corporations act 2001 cth act which enables an insolvent company and a creditor to setoff their mutual debts against each other to unfair preference claims.
In the supreme court of victoria not restricted at. Section 553c 2, corporations act ensures that setoff is not available where the party seeking the benefit, at the time of dealing with the company, had notice of the companys insolvency. The interplay between insolvency setoff provisions and a liquidators unfair preference claims has become more controversial in. Section 553c1 of the corporations act 2001 provides for a setoff where there have been mutual credits, mutual debts or other mutual dealings between an insolvent company that is being wound up and a person who wants to have a debt or claim admitted against the company. Can a directors liability for insolvent trading be. The right of setoff association of independent insolvency.
Section 553c is closely analogous to insolvency rule 14. An act to make provision in relation to corporations and financial products and services, and for other purposes. The interplay between insolvency setoff provisions and a liquidator s unfair preference claims has become more controversial in recent years. Setoff defence gains ground in unfair preference claims. However, the judge looked at section 553c of the corporations act and the arguments put by forges lawyers that that section precludes hamersley from relying on its contractual or equitable rights of setoff which would otherwise be available but for the insolvency of forge. In happier days it was a repairer, seller and broker of mining or quarrying equipment. When a company is placed into liquidation, section 553c operated as an exclusive code in respect of the settingoff of debts as between the. Set off provisions pursuant to section 553c of the. Section 553c of the corporations act 2001 cth act permits a person to setoff.
It includes any commenced amendment affecting the legislation to that date. Corporations act 2001 federal register of legislation. An account is to be taken of what is due from one party to the other in. Aasb means the australian accounting standards board. Insolvency setoff ousts contractors right to summary.
The brewing controversy in australia surrounding the. Response to s 672a disclosure notice by metals australia ltd company we confirm receipt of your direction to make the disclosure required by s 672b of the corporations act 2001 the act in respect of 50,241,396 securities registered in the name of anz nominees limited anz nominees as at 02nd april 2088 and respond below. The leading decision on the operation of section 553c of the act in the context of insolvent trading is re parker. Australian insolvency law regulates the position of companies which are in financial distress and are unable to pay or provide for all of their debts or other obligations, and matters ancillary to and arising from financial distress. Among the exceptions to the pari passu rule in australia is insolvency setoff, as provided for under s 553c of the corporations act 2001 cth the act. Legislation highlighted section 553c corporations act. The contractor submitted that it was entitled to set off its counterclaims against the subcontractors entitlements under the sop act, pursuant to section 553c of the corporations act. Building and construction industry security of payment act 1999 nsw corporations act 2001 cth administration under deed of company arrangement proof of debt setoff against judgment debt under s 553c of the corporations act how the proof of. An adjudicator considering an application under the cca in circumstances where the contractor is insolvent must apply s 553c of the corporations act 2001 cth s553c in reaching its determination. Major decision on setoff and security interests in. Best interests duty and related obligations december 2012.
The concept of mutuality applies under s 553c of the corporations act equivalent to section 310 of the companies act 1993 because the companies retained the right to use amounts under the contracts for their own benefit, despite any existing security interests setoff is not confined to unsecured debts. Corporations act 2001 documents relating to a current. Corporations act 2001 sect 553c insolvent companiesmutual credit and setoff 1 subject to subsection 2, where there have been mutual credits, mutual debts or other mutual dealings between an insolvent company that is being wound up and a person who wants to have a debt or claim admitted against the company. Only the balance of the account is admissible to proof against the company, or is payable to the company, as the case may be. Insolvency setoff applies where there have been mutual credits, mutual debts or. Abn short for australian business number has the meaning given by section 41 of the a new tax system australian business number act 1999. The corporations act 2001 cth the act bestows a positive duty on directors to prevent a company from incurring a debt whilst it is insolvent or where they suspect it is likely to become insolvent. Section 553c, corporations act is a statutory directive an account is to be taken. Ability to setoff insolvent trading or unfair preference.
Section 553 of the corporations law will be repealed and replaced and proposed sections. For example, this limitation on setoff will apply where a creditor of. The corporate law reform bill 1992 contains amendments to the. Among the exceptions to the pari passu rule in australia is insolvency setoff, as provided for under s 553c of the corporations act 2001 cth. As the respondent did not have notice of the applicants insolvency at that time, s 553c2 did not apply in this case. The law in this area is principally governed by the corporations act 2001. Can a setoff under s 553c be relied on as a defence to the various statutory recovery claims available to a companys liquidator under the corporations act e. Section 553c of the corporations act provides a statutory setoff scheme which operates where there have been mutual credits, mutual debts or other mutual dealings between an insolvent company that is being wound up, and a person who has a debt or claim against the insolvent company. Can creditors apply both a running account and setoff. Hfw corporations act trumps security of payment legislation for. Legislation highlighted section 553c corporations act setoffs on 1 february 2010 almost 5 years ago in april 2005 we published an article in this newsletter series on the availability of settingoff debts under section 553c of the corporations act.
In 2015, queensland district court judge searles held that section 553c of the corporations act 2001 cth the act may apply in situations to reduce a liquidators unfair preference claim, by allowing the amount still owing to a creditor to be setoff against the liquidators claim. Schedules preliminary 1 definitions, interpretation and governing law 1. Trustee corporations corporations act 2001 cth s 4332 where creditors. Insolvent companies s 553c hlb mann judd insolvency wa. Jhfjvs counsel submitted, without notice to my solicitors prior to the hearing, that the court was not. Liquidators argue that under section 553c1 of the corporations act 2001 act a creditor is not able to setoff the outstanding. Set off provisions pursuant to section 553c of the corporations act. Setoff against statutory avoidance and insolvent trading claims in company liquidation rory derham the purpose of this article is to consider whether a setoff under s 553c of the corporations act 2001cth may be relied on as a defence to the various statutory recovery claims available to a companys liquidator under the act. The western australian supreme court was asked to consider whether contractual or equitable setoff was available in insolvency, but chose to give precedence to setoff under s 553c. Corporations act 2001 sect 533 reports by liquidator 1 if it appears to the liquidator of a company, in the course of a winding up of the company, that. Under section 553c2 of the corporations act, a person may not claim the benefit of a setoff if that person had notice of the fact that. The effect was that, at the time that forge was placed into liquidation as this is the crucial time when mutuality is to be assessed, the dealings between hamersley and forge under the contracts were mutual dealings within the meaning of section 553c of the corporations act, notwithstanding the bank s security interest 2. Corporations act trumps security of payment legislation. Deregistrationderegistration of companies dissolved under the state bank corporatisation act 1994 of south australia 1441.
1229 518 1014 151 563 579 820 861 574 1363 960 295 405 1285 1451 340 716 241 978 766 907 1028 603 804 634 871 592 641 901 1191 1413 646 545 151 1153 554 1142 694 1405 163 1116 94